Which Is The Best AI Detection Tool? (BIG Surprise!)

Jason West
16 May 202311:16

TLDRIn this video, Jason tests various AI detection tools to determine which is the best at identifying AI-generated content. Using Chat GBT and GPT4, he generates an article with light humor to trick detectors. After analyzing recent trends in AI detection, he evaluates tools like Winston AI, AI Detector Pro, and GPT Zero. Winston and Originality prove most effective, while OpenAI's own detector and others fail to detect AI content accurately.

Takeaways

  • 😲 The video tests various AI detection tools to determine which is the best at detecting AI-generated content.
  • 📅 The video was made in mid-May 2023, reflecting the state of AI detection tools at that time.
  • 📝 The presenter uses ChatGPT to generate a 500-word article with human-like writing and humor to test the tools.
  • 🌐 Google Trends data shows a significant rise in interest in AI detection, particularly in African nations, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.
  • 🔍 The presenter discusses the popularity of Turnitin as an AI detection tool, mostly used by educational institutions.
  • 📈 Winston AI and Originality are identified as the top AI detection tools that successfully identified the AI-generated article.
  • 📉 Other tools like GPT Zero, CrossPlag, and a Chrome plugin called Percent Human failed to detect the AI-generated content.
  • 🤖 OpenAI's own detector classified the AI-generated text as very unlikely to be generated by AI, indicating a potential flaw.
  • 📊 Winston AI offers a dashboard to manage projects and check for plagiarism, as well as the ability to upload various file types for scanning.
  • 🌐 Originality provides a website scanner feature, useful for scanning entire websites for AI-generated content.
  • 🔗 The video provides a link to chatgptdetectors.com for viewers to explore and test various AI detection tools.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video?

    -The main purpose of the video is to test the latest AI detection tools to determine which one is the best at detecting AI-generated content.

  • When was the video recorded?

    -The video was recorded in the middle of May 2023.

  • What method does Jason use to trick the AI detection tools?

    -Jason uses the method of generating content with Chat GPT, using GPT4, and incorporating tricks often suggested in comments on his videos.

  • What is the first task Jason assigns to Chat GPT?

    -The first task Jason assigns to Chat GPT is to write a 500-word article on how AI-generated content can help small business owners accelerate the growth of their company.

  • What instructions does Jason give to Chat GPT when writing the article?

    -Jason instructs Chat GPT to write the article as if it were a human and to include occasional bits of light humor.

  • What does Jason observe about the interest in AI detection tools according to Google Trends?

    -Jason observes that there has been a significant increase in interest in AI detection tools over the last four months, with particularly high interest in regions like Kenya, Tunisia, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.

  • What is the most popular AI detection tool mentioned in the video?

    -The most popular AI detection tool mentioned in the video is Turnitin, which is commonly used by educational institutions.

  • Which AI detection tools were able to detect the AI-generated article?

    -The AI detection tools that were able to detect the AI-generated article were Winston and Originality.

  • What is the result of the AI detection test using GPT-0?

    -The AI detection test using GPT-0 indicated that the text is likely to be written entirely by a human, suggesting that GPT-0 was not able to detect the AI-generated content.

  • What additional features do Winston and Originality offer?

    -Winston offers a dashboard with project management features and the ability to scan various file types, while Originality offers a website scanner for checking entire websites for AI-generated content.

  • What is the conclusion of the video regarding the best AI detection tools?

    -The conclusion of the video is that Winston and Originality seem to be the better detectors of AI-generated content.

Outlines

00:00

🤖 Testing AI Detection Tools

In this segment, the host, Jason, introduces a video focused on evaluating the latest AI detection tools to determine their effectiveness. It is May 2023, and the host plans to trick these tools by using Chat GPT and GPT4 to generate content. He will employ various tactics often suggested by viewers in comments to see if they can deceive AI detection. Jason instructs Chat GPT to write a 500-word article on how AI can help small businesses grow, incorporating humor to make it appear human-written. While the article is being written, Jason reviews recent developments in AI detection tools and notes a significant increase in interest since December, with a focus on regions like Kenya, Tunisia, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines. He also discusses the popularity of Turnitin for educational institutions to detect AI-generated content. Finally, Jason reviews the article produced by GPT4, which is upbeat and humorous, and prepares to test it against various AI detectors.

05:00

🔍 Analyzing AI Detection Tool Performance

Jason tests the article generated by GPT4 using several AI detection tools, including Winston AI and AI Detector Pro. He encounters a limitation with AI Detector Pro, which requires a paid plan for full functionality. The results from Winston AI indicate a high likelihood that the text was AI-generated. GPT Zero, however, mistakenly classifies the text as human-written, suggesting it is not as effective as believed. Jason also tests other tools like CrossPlag and a Chrome plugin called Percent Human, which also fail to detect AI generation. OpenAI's own detector also incorrectly identifies the text as human-written. Jason concludes that Winston and Originality are the most effective tools, with Winston offering a user-friendly dashboard for document scanning and Originality providing a website scanner feature. He provides a link to a list of all tested AI detectors for viewers to explore.

10:03

📈 Conclusion on AI Detection Tools

In the final part of the video, Jason summarizes the findings, highlighting that Winston and Originality are the superior AI detection tools based on the test with the Chat GPT-generated article. He invites viewers to visit chatgptdetectors.com to access the full list of AI detectors tested and encourages them to find the best one for their needs. The host thanks viewers for watching and hints at the next video, maintaining viewer engagement with a call to like and subscribe.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI detection tools

AI detection tools are technologies designed to identify content generated by artificial intelligence, such as that produced by ChatGPT or GPT-4. These tools analyze text for patterns and characteristics that are indicative of AI authorship. In the video, the host tests various AI detection tools to determine their effectiveness at identifying content created by AI, particularly when compared to human writing. The tools are evaluated based on their accuracy, speed, and ability to detect AI-generated content even when it's mixed with human writing or includes humor, which are tactics people might use to trick the detectors [^1^].

💡Chat GPT

Chat GPT, or more specifically ChatGPT, is a type of AI language model developed by OpenAI that can generate human-like text. In the context of the video, ChatGPT is used to create content that the host then tries to trick AI detection tools into believing is human-written. The effectiveness of AI detection tools is measured by their ability to accurately identify content generated by ChatGPT [^1^].

💡GPT-4

GPT-4 is a version of the Generative Pre-trained Transformer developed by OpenAI, capable of generating coherent and contextually relevant text. The video discusses using GPT-4 to generate content that AI detection tools are then tested against. The mention of GPT-4 in the script indicates an attempt to challenge the AI detection tools with content from a more advanced AI model [^1^].

💡Google Trends

Google Trends is a public web facility of Google that shows how often a particular search-term is entered relative to the total search-volume across various regions of the world, and in various languages. In the video, Google Trends is referenced as a tool to demonstrate the growing interest in AI detection, indicating a surge in searches related to AI detection tools and their use in education and content creation [^1^].

💡Turnitin

Turnitin is an online plagiarism detection service that provides tools for educators to check students' work for similarity against the internet, academic publications, and student papers. The video mentions Turnitin as a related query in Google Trends, suggesting that educators are seeking ways to detect AI-generated content, possibly because students might be using AI to complete assignments [^1^].

💡Humor

In the context of the video, humor is used as a tactic to make AI-generated content appear more human-like. The host instructs ChatGPT to include light humor in the content it generates, aiming to test whether AI detection tools can distinguish humorous content that's written by AI as opposed to a human [^1^].

💡Plagiarism

Plagiarism refers to the act of using another person's work or ideas without giving credit to the original source. In the video, the host mentions that AI detection tools are sometimes used in conjunction with plagiarism checkers to ensure the originality of content. The mention of plagiarism in the transcript highlights the broader context in which AI detection tools are used [^1^].

💡Winston AI

Winston AI is one of the AI detection tools tested in the video. It is noted for its ability to detect AI-generated content with high accuracy. The tool is praised for its features such as a nice dashboard, project management, and the ability to check for plagiarism, making it a comprehensive tool for content analysis [^1^].

💡Originality

Originality is another top-performing AI detection tool mentioned in the video. It is highlighted for its website scanner feature, which allows users to scan entire websites for AI-generated content. This tool is particularly useful for website creators and publishers who want to ensure the originality of the content on their sites [^1^].

💡GPTZero

GPTZero is an AI detection tool that the host of the video found to be less effective than Winston AI and Originality. Despite being fast and user-friendly, GPTZero was not as accurate in detecting AI-generated content, especially when the content was generated by more advanced models like ChatGPT [^1^].

Highlights

Testing the latest AI detection tools to determine the best one available.

AI detection tools are being tested with content generated by Chat GPT and GPT4.

The video was created in mid-May 2023, reflecting the current state of AI detection tools.

AI detection tools have seen a surge in interest, particularly in African nations, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.

Turnitin is a popular tool for detecting AI-generated content, especially used by educational institutions.

AI-generated content is written to mimic human writing, including the use of humor.

The article generated by Chat GPT is upbeat and human-styled, with more humor than requested.

Winston AI and AI Detector Pro are among the AI detection tools being tested.

Some AI detection tools require a paid plan to access full functionality.

GPT-0 is a highly regarded AI detection tool but may not be as effective as believed.

Cross Plag and Open AI's own detector failed to detect AI-generated content in the test.

Winston and Originality are the top AI detection tools that successfully identified AI-generated content.

Winston AI offers a user-friendly dashboard for project management and document scanning.

Originality has a website scanner feature, useful for scanning entire websites for AI-generated content.

The video provides a comprehensive list of AI detection tools for viewers to explore.

The video concludes that Winston and Originality are currently the best AI detection tools available.