Every undetectable AI writer vs. every AI content detector

There's An AI For That
4 Dec 202305:31

TLDRThis video explores the competition between 'undetectable' AI writers and AI content detectors. The host tests 10 AI writers and 20 detectors to determine if these advanced tools can fool each other. While some AI writers claim to be undetectable, like 'Hide My AI' and 'GPT INF,' top content detectors like 'Winston AI' still catch most rewrites. The challenge involves rewriting an essay, cover letter, and short story, showing that neither side completely dominates. The video emphasizes that while AI technology is advancing, no AI writer or detector is perfect yet.

Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ AI writers have evolved to the point where they can mimic human writing with impressive accuracy, and are now being labeled 'undetectable.'
  • ๐Ÿค– This test compares 10 undetectable AI writers and 20 AI content detectors to see which side has the upper hand.
  • ๐Ÿ’ฐ A total of $269 was spent on acquiring undetectable AI writers and AI content detectors for the test.
  • ๐Ÿ“ The test involved rewriting three types of text: a historical essay, a cover letter, and a fantasy story.
  • โŒ Some tools failed early in the testing process, including Undetectable GPT (AI writer) and AI Content Checker (detector).
  • ๐Ÿ† Hide My AI performed best among the AI writers, only being detected by two AI content detectors in one test.
  • ๐ŸŽฏ Winston AI was the top-performing AI content detector, successfully identifying AI-written content in most cases.
  • ๐Ÿ” GPT INF was the only AI writer to achieve a perfect score in one of the tests, going completely undetected.
  • ๐Ÿ“‰ Humanized AI was ranked the worst undetectable AI writer based on the overall results of the tests.
  • ๐Ÿ”ฎ The future battle between undetectable AI writers and AI content detectors remains undecided, as both continue to improve.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video?

    -The video aims to test how undetectable AI writers fare against AI content detectors to determine which is more effective.

  • How many undetectable AI writers were tested in the video?

    -10 undetectable AI writers were tested in the video.

  • What were the three types of text used for testing the AI writers?

    -The three types of text used for testing were an essay on colonial America, a cover letter for a software engineering job, and a fantasy short story.

  • Which AI writer received a perfect score in one of the tests?

    -GPT INF was the only AI writer to receive a perfect score in the fantasy short story test.

  • Which AI content detector performed the best overall?

    -Winston AI was the best-performing AI content detector, with an almost perfect score.

  • How did the best-performing AI writers rank in the tests?

    -Hide My AI and GPT INF were the best-performing AI writers, with GPT INF achieving a perfect score in one test.

  • What was the price range for the undetectable AI writers mentioned in the video?

    -The prices for the undetectable AI writers ranged from $5 per month for Hide My AI to $349 per month for GPT INF.

  • Which AI writer was ranked the lowest in the tests?

    -Humanized AI ranked the lowest among the undetectable AI writers.

  • How much was spent on AI writers and content detectors for the test?

    -A total of $75.99 was spent on undetectable AI writers and $193.19 on AI content detectors.

  • What conclusion did the video reach about AI writers and detectors?

    -The video concluded that neither AI writers nor detectors completely dominate the other, as both sides can still be fooled under certain conditions.

Outlines

00:00

๐Ÿค– AI Writers vs. AI Content Detectors โ€“ The Ultimate Test

AI writers have evolved to the point where they can mimic human writing with alarming precision, and some are being dubbed 'undetectable.' In this experiment, AI writer tools were tested against AI content detectors to see how undetectable they really are. The test featured 10 AI writing tools and 20 detection tools, including popular ones like 'Hide My AI' and 'Winston AI.' The aim was to determine whether modern AI content detectors could still identify AI-generated text, using three unique types of content: an essay on colonial America, a cover letter for a software engineering job, and a fantasy short story. The experiment also revealed that several tools, including 'Undetectable GPT' and 'AI Content Checker,' dropped out early due to errors. With the remaining tools, 'Hide My AI' and 'Winston AI' emerged as early leaders.

05:02

๐Ÿ“ AI Writers vs. Content Detectors: Round One โ€“ The Essay

The first test was an essay on colonial America, and the results were mixed. 'Hide My AI' performed the best among the writers, with only two detectorsโ€”Winston AI and AI Cheat Checkโ€”being able to flag it as AI-generated. On the other hand, 'Winston AI' dominated the detection side, flagging almost all essays except one generated by 'GPT INF.' Other notable AI detectors like 'Interested in AI' also performed well, detecting several essays. Despite the high competition, there was still a clear performance gap between the top-performing and lower-performing tools on both sides.

๐Ÿ“„ Cover Letter Challenge: AI Writers Try to Stay Undetected

In the second test, the AI writers attempted to generate a cover letter for a software engineering job application. 'Hide My AI' maintained its lead, this time tying with 'Stealth Rider,' both being detected by only two AI detectors: Winston AI and AI Undetect. On the detection side, 'Winston AI' achieved a perfect score, proving to be the strongest tool once again. 'Check for AI' and 'GPT 0' also performed well, while 'Interested in AI' struggled, detecting only one letter. As the tests progressed, 'Winston AI' proved itself as the most reliable AI content detector in the competition.

๐Ÿง™ Fantasy Story Test: AI Writers Face the Final Challenge

For the third and final test, the AI writers had to generate a fantasy short story featuring orcs and elves. 'GPT INF' achieved a perfect score by going completely undetected by all the AI content detectors, a first in the entire experiment. 'Hide My AI' remained a close second, continuing to show its consistency, while 'AI Text Converter' fell to the bottom of the ranking. On the detection side, 'Winston AI' once again led the pack, though it was confounded by 'GPT INF.' 'Check for AI' followed in second place. The fantasy short story test underscored the strengths and weaknesses of both sides as they battled for supremacy.

๐Ÿ† The Final Verdict: Top AI Writers and Content Detectors Revealed

At the end of the tests, 'Hide My AI' and 'GPT INF' were declared the best undetectable AI writers, with 'GPT INF' earning extra credit for achieving a perfect score in one of the tests. The pricing for these tools varies, with 'GPT INF' starting at $12 per month and going up to $349, while 'Hide My AI' offers a free trial and a paid version at $5 per month. On the detection side, 'Winston AI' emerged as the clear winner, with near-perfect detection across all tests, followed by 'Check for AI' and 'GPT 0.' Both writing and detection tools are rapidly advancing, and while neither side has complete dominance yet, itโ€™s clear that the competition is intense. The future of undetectable AI writing and content detection remains uncertain, but this experiment provided valuable insights.

Mindmap

Keywords

๐Ÿ’กUndetectable AI Writers

These are AI tools designed to rewrite content in a way that makes it difficult for AI content detectors to identify them as machine-generated. They mimic human writing styles with high precision. Examples mentioned in the video include 'GPT INF,' 'Hide My AI,' and 'Stealth Writer.' The video explores how effective these tools are when tested against AI content detectors.

๐Ÿ’กAI Content Detectors

These are tools developed to identify text generated by AI. They scan content to determine whether it is machine-written. In the video, various detectors like 'Winston AI,' 'Check for AI,' and 'Zero GPT' are put to the test against undetectable AI writers to see if they can accurately detect rewritten AI content.

๐Ÿ’กWinston AI

Winston AI is one of the AI content detectors mentioned in the video. It comes out on top in most tests, detecting almost all instances of AI-generated content. Despite some instances where it was fooled, Winston AI is highlighted as one of the most effective detectors.

๐Ÿ’กGPT INF

GPT INF is an undetectable AI writer that performed exceptionally well in the tests. It was the only tool to achieve a perfect score in one of the tests (the fantasy short story), making it one of the top undetectable AI writers. Its effectiveness demonstrates the evolving capabilities of AI writers in avoiding detection.

๐Ÿ’กContent Rewrite

This refers to the process of using AI writers to modify AI-generated text so that it appears more human-like. The video discusses how undetectable AI writers can rewrite content, such as essays or cover letters, and whether AI content detectors can still identify these rewritten texts as AI-generated.

๐Ÿ’กDetection Tests

The video involves multiple tests to evaluate the effectiveness of both AI writers and AI detectors. These tests include rewriting an essay about colonial America, a software engineering cover letter, and a fantasy short story. The results are used to gauge the ability of various AI tools to either rewrite content undetectably or detect AI-generated content.

๐Ÿ’กHumanize AI

One of the undetectable AI writers featured in the video. However, it performed poorly compared to other tools in terms of avoiding detection by AI content detectors. Its low scores make it the 'worst' among the undetectable AI writers tested in the video.

๐Ÿ’กCost of AI Tools

The video mentions the cost of purchasing undetectable AI writers and AI content detectors. The total cost was $269.189, with undetectable AI writers costing $75.99 and the AI detectors costing $193.191. It provides insight into the monetary investment required for these AI tools.

๐Ÿ’กFuture of AI Writing and Detection

Towards the end, the video poses the question of how undetectable AI writers and AI content detectors will evolve in the future. It raises a debate on which side โ€“ AI writers or detectors โ€“ will eventually 'win,' reflecting on the ongoing battle between AI generation and AI detection technology.

๐Ÿ’กAI Content Generation Challenge

This phrase encapsulates the main theme of the video, which is the competition between AI writers and detectors. The challenge is to see if undetectable AI writers can successfully bypass the scrutiny of advanced AI detectors and if detectors have evolved enough to expose even the most sophisticated AI-generated content.

Highlights

AI writers are evolving to mimic human writing with high precision, becoming undetectable.

The test compares 10 undetectable AI writers against 20 AI content detectors.

The competition aims to find out if AI writers can still be detected by AI content detectors.

Undetectable AI writers work by rewriting AI-generated texts to make them appear more human.

Some AI content detectors dropped out early due to errors during the testing phase.

Winston AI is the most effective AI content detector, detecting most of the rewritten essays.

Hide My AI was the top performer among the undetectable AI writers in the essay test.

Humanize AI consistently performed the worst among the undetectable AI writers.

GPT INF was the only AI writer to achieve a perfect score, going undetected in the fantasy short story test.

Winston AI continued to perform well, detecting most rewritten texts across different tests.

AI content detectors like Winston AI and Check for AI had near-perfect scores in identifying AI-generated content.

Despite advancements, no side completely dominates; some AI writers can still fool the best detectors.

Hide My AI and GPT INF emerged as the top undetectable AI writers after all tests.

Winston AI was crowned the best AI content detector, nearly achieving a perfect score.

The future of undetectable AI writing versus AI content detection remains uncertain, as both continue to advance.